Single Island Shores has quietly become one of the best places to stay in the entire Finger Lakes — and the reviews say it better than we could. The combination of private cottages, real lake access, and a location that puts you within five minutes of more wineries than you can visit in a weekend is hard to beat.
What keeps people coming back is Ashley and the team. The hospitality here is genuinely warm — guests consistently mention how well-maintained everything is, how quickly issues get resolved, and how much the staff cares. The dock at sunset, the fire pit with s'mores, and the view from the upper lakeview cottages at dawn are the kinds of things that turn a wine weekend into a Finger Lakes tradition.